Leadership stability is foundational for organizational effectiveness and mission fulfillment in the nonprofit sector. Yet, recent trends reveal unprecedented challenges as C-suite executive turnover rates escalate to record levels in 2025. Drawing from my experience as a nonprofit and education executive combined with current sector data, this article synthesizes key facts about turnover rates, underlying causes, salary dynamics, and evolving leadership models. My goal is to inform and empower nonprofit leaders navigating these challenges.
Escalating Turnover Rates Across Nonprofit C-Suite Roles
Nonprofit organizations are experiencing significant leadership churn. The turnover rate for nonprofit C-suite executives—including Chief Executive Officers (CEOs), Chief Financial Officers (CFOs), Chief Program Officers (CPOs), Chief Development Officers (CDOs), and Chief Operating Officers (COOs)—has reached approximately 25% over two years, or about 12–13% annually (Challenger, Gray & Christmas, 2025; BizJournals, 2025). This is notably higher than the all-industry average turnover of roughly 12%, with voluntary turnover in nonprofits generally estimated around 19% annually (Nonprofit HR, 2020; NonprofitHR.com, 2025).
Among C-suite roles, CEO turnover is especially acute. Approximately 860 nonprofit CEO departures were reported by April 2025, marking a 15% increase from 2024 (BizJournals, 2025). CFO turnover has also surged, with some sectors reporting a 45% increase, reflecting role expansion and heightened pressures (DigitalDefynd, 2025). While precise data on turnover for CPOs and COOs are less publicly available, these roles similarly face high stress and retention risks due to operational demands. Development leadership is notably volatile with CDOs often departing within 18–24 months, given intense fundraising pressures (Avra Search, 2025).
Drivers of the Turnover Wave: Burnout, Compensation, and Structural Challenges
Multiple factors underlie this leadership exodus. Burnout is pervasive among nonprofit executives, fueled by increasing operational demands, financial uncertainty, and sociopolitical complexities. Surveys indicate that up to 70% of C-suite executives are at risk of burnout, with many reporting worsening mental health and seeking less stressful opportunities (Sigma Assessment Systems, 2025; Johnson Center for Philanthropy, 2025). Compensation dissatisfaction is another major factor: nonprofit salaries lag behind private sector counterparts, with nonprofit CEOs typically earning between $150,000 and $250,000, depending on the organization’s size and mission—significantly less than for-profit peers (Avra Search, 2025; DigitalDefynd, 2025).
Career advancement opportunities appear limited; data show that about 45% of nonprofit employees plan to seek new roles by 2025, often citing pay and growth limitations as key reasons (Nonprofit HR, 2020). Demographically, the sector faces a substantial “silver tsunami” retirement wave among executives aged 55 and older, intensifying leadership turnover (Bonadio Group, 2024).
Boards also experience pressure amid economic volatility and heightened stakeholder demands, accelerating leadership transitions. This creates challenges for organizational culture and continuity, making succession planning a paramount priority (Sigma Assessment Systems, 2025; Urban Institute, 2025).
Emergence of the ‘CEO Gig Economy’ and Interim Leadership
One striking development reshaping nonprofit leadership is the rise of interim and project-based CEOs. Data show that 33% of new CEO appointments in 2025 were interim, up from just 9% in 2024 (Challenger, Gray & Christmas, 2025; BizJournals, 2025). This trend reflects a shift toward shorter, more flexible leadership tenures aligned with both organizational needs and executive preferences.
While interim leadership provides agility and fresh viewpoints, it challenges building trust, cultural cohesion, and strategic continuity. Teams under interim CEOs may struggle with engagement and morale, issues I have observed personally in nonprofits facing frequent leadership changes.
Compensation Landscape: Balancing Mission and Market Realities
Typical salary ranges in 2025 for nonprofit C-suite roles vary by position and organizational size:
| Role | Salary Range (USD) | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Chief Executive Officer | $150,000 – $250,000 (up to $745,000 in large orgs) | Larger nonprofits, especially in healthcare/education, pay more (Avra Search, 2025). |
| Chief Financial Officer | $100,000 – $200,000 | CFO roles are expanding, driving upward compensation trends (DigitalDefynd, 2025). |
| Chief Program Officer | $90,000 – $180,000 | Varies by size and mission complexity. |
| Chief Development Officer | $90,000 – $170,000 | Fundraising pressures cause role volatility affecting pay. |
| Chief Operations Officer | $100,000 – $200,000 | Critical for operational stability in complex nonprofits. |
Nonprofit CEO salaries represent about 75% of comparable for-profit CEO pay, though within larger nonprofits, compensation can reach much higher levels (DigitalDefynd, 2025). The sector has seen modest salary increases around 3–4% projected through 2025, though pay gaps and workload stresses continue to affect retention (NonprofitHR.com, 2025; DigitalDefynd, 2025).
Toward Sustainable Leadership and Flourishing Organizations
The unprecedented turnover in nonprofit leadership signals an urgent call to action. Based on my leadership experience, I advocate for nonprofits to prioritize strong succession planning, integrate leadership wellness programs, and cultivate career pathways that align mission commitment with personal growth. Boards must strengthen cultural continuity even amid inevitable transitions and strategically utilize interim leadership while seeking long-term placements.
The rise of the “CEO gig economy” reflects a wider transformation in leadership expectations. Nonprofits and their leaders must adapt by embracing flexible, accountable leadership models and addressing systemic challenges such as compensation equity, burnout, and inclusion to build a sustainable, resilient workforce.
By innovating leadership development and fostering organizational culture, nonprofits can turn turnover challenges into opportunities for renewal, ensuring vitality for both leaders and their missions over the long term.
Reach out to us at Flourishing Vitality to ensure your leaders are equipped to avoid burnout amid the challenges at hand.
References
Avra Search. (2025). 2025 nonprofit executive director and CEO hiring trends. Retrieved August 2025, from https://www.avrasearch.com/insights/2025-nonprofit-executive-director-ceo-hiring
BizJournals. (2025, July 28). A turnover tsunami is hitting the C-suite — and sparking a ‘CEO gig economy’. Retrieved August 2025, from https://www.bizjournals.com/bizjournals/news/2025/07/28/record-turnover-ceo-gig-economy-challenger.html
Challenger, Gray & Christmas. (2025, July 29). The rise of the CEO gig economy: Turnover in the corner office. Fortune. Retrieved August 2025, from https://fortune.com/2025/07/29/ceo-gig-economy-turnover-highest-in-decades/
DigitalDefynd. (2025). 100 interesting C-suite facts and statistics [2025]. Retrieved August 2025, from https://digitaldefynd.com/IQ/interesting-c-suite-facts-and-statistics/
Johnson Center for Philanthropy. (2025, January 14). The nonprofit workforce is in crisis. Retrieved August 2025, from https://johnsoncenter.org/blog/the-nonprofit-workforce-is-in-crisis/
Nonprofit HR. (2020, February 10). 45% of nonprofit employees to seek new jobs by 2025: Report. Forbes. Retrieved August 2025, from https://www.forbes.com/sites/chrisstrub/2020/02/10/nonprofithr/
NonprofitHR.com. (2025, March 26). 2025 compensation trends: Wage growth & labor market insights. Retrieved August 2025, from https://www.nonprofithr.com/the-2025-compensation-landscape/
Sigma Assessment Systems. (2025, May 27). Crisis in the C-suite: How to prepare for the wave of CEO exits. Retrieved August 2025, from https://www.sigmaassessmentsystems.com/crisis-in-the-c-suite-how-to-prepare-for-the-wave-of-ceo-exits/
Urban Institute. (2025, April). Nonprofit leaders’ top concerns entering 2025 [PDF]. Retrieved August 2025, from https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/2025-04/Nonprofit_Leaders%E2%80%99_Top_Concerns_Entering_2025.pdf
Flourishing Vitality 